Good governance means asking difficult questions
Last week, our Board Chair David Sharp, CEO Dena Dalton, Leadership Development and Training Manager Mike Hickman and Junior Development Officer, Claire Smith attended the 35th Wrigleys Charity Governance Conference in Leeds. Afterwards, Mike Hickman reflected on the take-away moments. He writes:
What happens when your email goes down? It sounds like a technical question doesn’t it?
But at this year’s Wrigleys Charity Governance Conference, it became a much bigger one: how well do we understand the risks facing our organisations, and how ready are we to respond?
We came away with plenty to think about when approaching our work with the voluntary, community and social enterprise (VCSE) sector.
For an infrastructure organisation like ours, the value is not just in what we learn. It is in what we do with that learning: the questions our development officers ask, the training we offer, the leadership mentoring we provide and the priorities we set. Just as importantly, we need to turn those questions on ourselves.
Technology should serve the mission, not set it
Keynote speaker Victoria Speight, CEO, founder and director of Cyberfit, explored the challenges and opportunities of cyber security and AI, keeping the people behind the technology firmly in view. One message stayed with me: pause and evaluate. Before asking how to adopt a new tool, ask whether we need it, and whether it supports our mission.
The discussion also raised a question about critical thinking. If AI takes on more of the work, how do we protect the space for people to question, challenge and exercise judgement? For us, that means thinking about the culture of our workshops and workplaces, not simply the tools we use in them.
The scale of cyber risk described at the conference was sobering. But the most useful response is not fear. It is a willingness to look honestly at our own arrangements and ask what needs to change.
Prevent, respond, recover: before the crisis
Nick Dunn and Peter Parker of Wrigleys built on this theme in their session – Prevent, Respond, Recover: A Data Breach Guide for Charity Leaders. Their session challenged us to plan on the basis that cyberattacks can happen, rather than treating them as somebody else’s problem.
The practical questions were direct:
- Does everything really need to be connected to the internet?
- Do we know where our data is stored?
- What are our contingency plans?
- If email becomes unavailable, how will we keep working and communicating?
That last question felt particularly timely. The session asked us to consider an email outage; the following day, problems accessing Outlook brought the question into sharp focus for so many people around the world. A contingency plan matters most when the system we rely on is no longer there.
The discussion also brought reputational damage into focus. Beyond the immediate disruption, what would a breach mean for the trust people place in us? Cyber risk and data protection need to be questions for the whole board, not subjects we leave to whoever seems most technically confident.
Confidence is not the same as competence
One case study used a revealing detail: someone presenting themselves as an expert cited ISO 216 (a standard relating to paper sizes) to imply expertise in cybersecurity they did not have. Only one attendee recognised it, and – yes – we laughed. Of course we did. But what if we were presented with that scenario for real? What if AI was the one citing the inappropriate qualification or standard to us?
The point was not that every trustee should memorise technical standards. It was that we must feel able to ask questions, request evidence and challenge an answer we do not understand. Would we spot an attempt to blind us with jargon? And would we feel confident enough to say: “Please explain what that means for our organisation?”
Bring the learning back to the board table
The conference also turned from protecting information to recording it well, with Hayley Marsden and Ciaran Warters and their session – The Art of Good Minutes. Alongside the cyber discussions, it prompted a useful reflection: good governance is about both the information we safeguard and the records we create.
For us, the next step is to carry these questions into our support for the sector through conversations, training, webinars and leadership mentoring, while taking the same honest look at our own practice.
For trustees and leaders across the VCSE sector, here are three questions worth taking to your next meeting:
- Mission: Are our technology choices helping us do what we exist to do?
- Readiness: If our usual systems failed tomorrow, would we know what to do?
- Challenge: Can everyone around the table ask a difficult question and expect a clear answer?
We do not need to leave a conference with every answer. We do need to act on the questions that matter.
Good governance is not about sounding as though we have everything under control. It is about being willing to ask, listen, challenge, and act before a crisis forces our hand.
November 16, 2026 10:44 am